LJMU Initial Teacher Education Programme logo

PGCE/DE Primary 5-11

Formative Lesson Analysis

Lesson Observation and Analysis are key ‘formative’ activities during any placement experience. They are challenging activities, which are helped by having an agreed focus, and an opportunity to reflect on the issues emerging after the observation.

The LJMU Partnership agreement requires that in Phases 2 and 3, ITT mentors complete a minimum of 2 formal Lesson Analysis Forms per week and give time to engage in a verbal learning conversation with the trainee as a result. If a trainee teaches in Phase 1, written feedback is also essential. Lesson analysis forms have been co-designed with partners, via our steering committees, to ensure that they are constructive, manageable and give priority to evaluating and reflecting on learning.

Page 2 of the lesson analysis form is available for note taking, with key analysis and development points summarised on Page 1. Many school-based ITT mentors find it useful to jot down some notes on page 2 from initial observations of what is going on, in the order in which things happen. This is a useful preliminary process before analysing the learning on page 1. An agreed focus is helpful and reference to the achievement of the standards is important.

The partnership has agreed that all feedback to LJMU trainees should focus on the impact of the teaching on pupil learning. Post-lesson reflections should unpick how effective the teaching was in supporting all pupils to achieve.

How will Lesson Observation and Analysis help the Trainee Teacher?

It will:

  • develop the trainee’s capacity to evaluate and reflect on their practice in relation to pupil learning;
  • monitor the trainee’s success in achieving previously agreed targets;
  • develop and extend trainee’s subject and pedagogical knowledge;
  • identify the trainee’s key strengths and areas for development in teaching and their impact on pupils’ learning;
  • discuss strategies and ideas to help the trainee improve pupil learning and identify new targets;

 Written feedback, as described above, is important to ensure clear, mutual understanding and to provide a record. Verbal feedback in the form of a ‘learning conversation’ is equally important to trainee teachers. The verbal feedback should discuss both key strengths and areas for development, and be given as soon as practicable after the lesson.

 There will be occasions when the trainee is working with other teachers/members of the department. It is critical that the ITT mentor informs other staff of the expectations required for the Phase and the trainee’s individual targets and needs so that there is clear consensus and consistency in the training programme.

  It is also recommended that joint observations are carried out by ITT mentors and the professional mentor, enabling them to compare their assessments of the trainee, and to ensure that the expectation and feedback is consistent.

Some suggestions for conducting Formative Observation/Analysis and Feedback

In order for the formal lesson observations and analysis to be effective it is helpful to consider the following taking into account the Trainee’s Phase of training and individual needs:

Preparation for the Observation/Analysis

  • discuss the focus for the observation/analysis;
  • review the evaluation of the previous lesson and new lesson plan before the lesson;
  • note any particular issues about the lesson/pupils;
  • set aside the time to review the lesson afterwards.

During the Observation/Analysis

  • concentrate on the agreed focus of the observation/analysis and emphasise the impact on pupil learning;
  • be precise on strengths and areas for development, illustrated by specific examples;
  • identify pertinent and perceptive questions for the trainee to consider, which focus on  the pupils’ responses to their teaching and how learning might be improved.

During the Feedback Session

  • use your pertinent and perceptive questions to make this a learning conversation;
  • engage the trainee in a dialogue about which aspects of the learning went well and be able to support the trainee by looking at alternative approaches and strategies if necessary;
  • focus the trainee on their own subject knowledge development; how confident did they feel in addressing and exploring pupils’ questions and clarifying misconceptions?
  • consider including work scrutiny as part of your discussion; looking at pupils’ work can clarify how effective the lesson was in achieving its objectives;
  • support the trainee in monitoring their progress towards meeting the Teachers’ Standards and setting new and appropriate targets.

Some useful Guidance for Feedback Sessions:

  • set a constructive atmosphere and start with your own positive comment;
  • identify the strengths in pupil learning during the lesson ‘what do you think went well’ and ‘why do you think that was successful’
  • pick up on and develop the trainees’ answers by challenging/re directing their comments to engage them in deeper evaluation and reflection,
  • ask the trainee to identify any aspects of learning in the lesson that didn’t go so well or could have been handled differently ‘what would you change’ and ‘how’;
  • enable the trainee to consider other possible approaches and strategies;
  • support the trainee in identifying targets arising for the next lesson working through the points from your analysis;
  • summarise the main points and any that need following up and discussing at the weekly meeting, identify what support is available if needed;
  • leave the trainee feeling positive and with a ‘can do’ attitude.
Weekly Meeting Record